Home

Expertise

Our Practice

Agbaje v The Robert Frew Medical Company Limited [2023] EWCA CIV 702

Taylor Wood Solicitors acted for The Robert Frew Medical Company Limited in its successful Court of Appeal challenge to interest and costs orders arising from a compulsory share transfer. The decision clarifies when contractual purchase money becomes a debt, the limits of section 35A of the Senior Courts Act 1981, and the approach to costs where the eventual award is lower than sums previously offered.

Court of Appeal overturns interest and costs orders in GP company share dispute


Background


Dr Oluremi Agbaje was formerly a partner in the Robert Frew Medical Practice and held 1,600 shares in The Robert Frew Medical Company Limited, which owned the property used by the practice. When he ceased to be a partner, a 2006 shareholders' agreement triggered compulsory transfer provisions for his shares.


The company determined a transfer price of £24,000 and made repeated offers and tenders of payment. Dr Agbaje disputed the valuation. The proceedings he issued in October 2019 originally raised a number of claims against the company and individual shareholders. Much of the claim, including the claim for conversion of the shares, was struck out or summarily dismissed. The individual defendants were later removed from the proceedings, leaving the company as the sole defendant.


At trial, the remaining dispute concerned the correct valuation date and the value of the shares. The High Court accepted the single joint expert's valuation of £21,188 as at 18 April 2009. The company had offered £24,000, which was more than the court's valuation. The High Court nevertheless later ordered the company to pay interest at 4 per cent from 4 November 2011, amounting to £9,006.93, and made costs orders largely in Dr Agbaje's favour. The company appealed those consequential orders.


The issues before the Court of Appeal


The appeal raised three linked questions. First, had the interest judgment proceeded on factual or legal concessions that the company had never made? Second, was the remaining claim a proceeding for the recovery of a debt or damages within section 35A of the Senior Courts Act 1981? Third, who was the successful party for costs when the court's valuation was lower than the company's earlier offers?


The Court of Appeal decision


The Court of Appeal unanimously allowed the company's appeals. Arnold LJ held that the interest judgment could not stand because it rested on incorrect and unfair premises. The High Court had treated the company as having accepted non-compliance with the agreement, breach of contract and conversion of the shares. The company had made no such concessions. The reliance on conversion was particularly troubling because that cause of action had been struck out and removed from the amended particulars of claim.


The Court then examined the payment machinery in clause 11 of the shareholders' agreement. Where a departing shareholder was unwilling to transfer the shares, the company could act as the shareholder's attorney, complete the transfer and hold the purchase money on trust without interest. The shareholder became entitled to payment when the share certificate was delivered. Dr Agbaje had never surrendered his certificate. The company therefore had not become legally obliged to pay him the purchase money under the contractual mechanism.


The remaining claim was, as pleaded, one for specific performance and, as tried, a determination of the correct value of the shares. It was not a claim to recover a debt. The High Court therefore had no jurisdiction under section 35A to award interest. The Court of Appeal added that it would have refused interest in any event because Dr Agbaje had declined payments and offers exceeding the valuation he ultimately obtained.


The costs appeal also succeeded. The real dispute was the value of the shares, and the company had succeeded on that issue because the court's figure of £21,188 was lower than the £24,000 it had offered. The Court held that the first-instance judge had given inadequate weight to those offers and had wrongly relied on the struck-out conversion allegation. Dr Agbaje was ordered to pay the company's costs of the proceedings, except to the extent that costs had already been dealt with by orders left undisturbed.


Why the decision matters


The judgment confirms that an order resulting in the payment of money does not necessarily mean that the proceedings were for the recovery of a debt. The court must identify the cause of action, the relief sought and the contractual conditions that govern when payment becomes due. Where an agreement requires a further act before payment is payable, such as delivery of a share certificate, that condition may determine both whether a debt exists and whether statutory interest is available.


The decision also addresses procedural fairness in consequential judgments. A court should not decide interest or costs on the basis of an assumed concession, especially where the supposed concession concerns an allegation that is no longer pleaded. If a party's case has been misunderstood, the error must be identified promptly and by reference to the pleadings, orders and submissions.


On costs, the Court looked at the substance of the dispute and the parties' offers. A claimant's receipt of a payment order did not make him the successful party where the central contest was valuation and the amount recovered was lower than the sum already offered.


Our Practice

News & Publications

We’re listening.
Call 0203 786 1170

 News Main PageNext NewsPrevious News