Home

Expertise

Our Practice

Legal Insight- Regulatory Case Note

High Court examines discrimination evidence and procedural fairness in a section 40 appeal


In Agoe & Ali v GMC, the High Court considered allegations of race discrimination and abuse of process in a statutory appeal from the Medical Practitioners Tribunal. Although the appeal was dismissed, the judgment provides important guidance on comparator evidence, challenges to assertions made on instructions, procedural preservation and the Court's approach to tribunal findings and sanction.

Case: Agoe & Ali v General Medical Council [2025] EWHC 2075 (Admin)

Court: High Court, King's Bench Division, Administrative Court - Mrs Justice Farbey DBE and abuse of process in a statutory appeal from the Medical Practitioners Tribunal. Although the appeal was dismissed, the judgement provides important guidance on comparator evidence, challenges to assertions made on instructions, procedural preservation and the Court’s to tribunal findings and sanctions.

Outcome: Appeal dismissed

Hearing: 18 June 2025; judgment handed down 4 August 2025

Background

Dr Belinda Agoe and Dr Kausar Ali appealed under section 40 of the Medical Act 1983 against decisions of the Medical Practitioners Tribunal that led to their suspension from the Medical Register.

The underlying proceedings arose from events at Staunton Group Practice after the Care Quality Commission suspended the practice's registration and NHS England appointed Federated4Health to take over GP services under a caretaker arrangement. The Tribunal found, among other matters, that the doctors had obstructed the incoming caretaker's access and continued to deliver or organise patient services. It found their fitness to practise impaired by misconduct and imposed different periods of suspension.

The grounds of appeal

The appeal advanced eight grounds. The first group alleged that the GMC's decision to proceed against the appellants, while not investigating another GP said to be a white comparator, amounted to unlawful direct race discrimination. It was argued that the Tribunal should therefore have stayed the regulatory proceedings as an abuse of process. The remaining grounds challenged aspects of the Tribunal's factual findings, reasoning and choice of suspension rather than conditions of practice.

The Court’s decision

The High Court dismissed the appeal. On the discrimination grounds, the Court held that there was no evidence that the relevant GMC decision-makers knew the proposed comparator's race. The appellants had therefore not established facts from which unlawful discrimination could be inferred at the first stage of the burden-of-proof analysis under section 136 of the Equality Act 2010.

The Court also held that the comparator was not in materially the same circumstances. The evidence did not show that he had the same knowledge, had received and defied the same warnings, had obstructed the incoming caretaker, or had participated in the earlier tribunal proceedings in the same way.

A significant procedural point arose from a statement made by GMC counsel before the Tribunal, on instructions, that the Case Examiner did not know the comparator's race. The statement was not challenged at the time. The High Court held that, in the absence of a challenge, the Tribunal was entitled to treat counsel's statement as correct. The Court also noted that the appellants had not asked the Tribunal to adjourn the abuse-of-process hearing so that further evidence or inquiries could be obtained.

The factual and reasons challenges were rejected. The Court concluded that the Tribunal had an evidential basis for its findings and had given sufficient reasons. It also upheld the periods of suspension, holding that the Tribunal had considered the doctors separately, had explained the different sanctions and was entitled to conclude that conditions were not workable.

A note on earlier judicial review proceedings

The GMC argued that some grounds had already been raised in earlier judicial review proceedings and should not be relitigated. The Court considered that there was force in the res judicata and abuse-of-process arguments, but declined to determine the point because the effect of recent authority had not been fully argued. It therefore addressed the discrimination and abuse grounds on their merits. The judgment is nevertheless a warning about running overlapping public-law challenges and later statutory appeal grounds without a clear procedural strategy.

Practical lessons for regulatory cases


Discrimination allegations must be prepared as evidence-based legal claims. It is not enough to show that two doctors received different treatment. The proposed comparator must be in materially comparable circumstances, and the evidence must support the required inference about the regulator's decision-making.


Material assertions made by opposing counsel on instructions should be challenged expressly if they are disputed. Where a point cannot fairly be resolved without further evidence, an application for an adjournment or disclosure should be made and recorded. An appellate court may be slow to criticise a tribunal for deciding a point on the material before it when no such application was made.


Appeals against factual findings or sanction should identify a legal error, material evidential gap, inconsistency or failure to give adequate reasons. A disagreement with the Tribunal's evaluation will not ordinarily be enough, particularly where the specialist tribunal has addressed aggravating and mitigating factors and explained why a less restrictive sanction would not be workable.



Our Practice

News & Publications

Practical takeaway

Issues of discrimination, abuse of process and fairness should be evidenced and procedurally preserved at the Tribunal stage. Requests for disclosure, challenges to disputed assertions, applications for further evidence and objections to reasoning should be made clearly and at the time.

Our role

The appellants were represented by Oluwaseyi Ojo, Solicitors Advocate  of Taylor Wood Solicitors. The judgment is a public decision and records that the appeal was dismissed.

Sources

Judgment: Agoe & Ali v General Medical Council [2025] EWHC 2075 (Admin)
Public report: ICLG - Court rejects GPs' race discrimination appeal

We’re listening.
Call 0203 786 1170

 News Main PageNext NewsPrevious News