Home

Expertise

Our Practice

High Court protects continuity of a GMS contract after
partnership dissolution

Taylor Wood Solicitors acted in a successful High Court challenge concerning the survival of a General Medical Services contract following the dissolution and immediate reconstitution of a GP Partnership. The Court held that the contract had not automatically terminated and clarified the operation of Regulation 15 of the GMS Regulations.

Case: R (Bhat and another) v NHS Litigation Authority and another [2024] EWHC 375 (Admin)

Court: High Court, King's Bench Division, Administrative Court - Mrs Justice Lang DBE

Outcome: Claim for judicial review allowed

Hearing: 30 and 31 January 2024; judgment handed down 22 February 2024

The issue

The case concerned the legal consequences for a General Medical Services contract when a partnership at will was dissolved following an internal partnership dispute, but the medical practice continued without interruption through a reconstituted partnership.

Dr Vikram Bhat and Mrs Geetha Bhat operated Sai Medical Centre in Tilbury. They had been in partnership with Mrs Patel under a GMS contract. On 8 November 2021, the Bhats served notice dissolving that partnership. They continued to run the practice, retaining the premises, assets and liabilities of the business. There was no winding up and no interruption to patient services.

The local commissioner took the position that the dissolution had automatically terminated the GMS contract. An adjudicator appointed through the NHS dispute-resolution procedure accepted that analysis and concluded that only an implied fixed-term contract had arisen, expiring on 31 March 2022. The Bhats challenged that determination by judicial review.

The High Court's decision

Mrs Justice Lang allowed the claim. The Court held that the adjudicator had erred in law by treating dissolution as bringing the GMS contract to an automatic end.

Regulation 15 of the National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015, read with Schedule 1 of the contract, treated the contract as made with the partnership as constituted from time to time. The dissolution was technical because the business continued without a full-scale winding up, but the Court held that the result would have been the same even if it were characterised as general.

The Court rejected additional implied conditions. Regulation 15 did not depend on unanimous consent, a written partnership agreement, or the technical/general label. The contractor had to notify the commissioner of a change in composition but did not require approval for it.

The judgment distinguished reconstitution of a continuing partnership from a change of contractor status to a sole practitioner. Nominating a sole practitioner was an option for the latter situation, not a condition for continuing a contract with a reconstituted partnership.

Why the decision matters

The judgment protects continuity in primary care. A partnership dispute and dissolution do not, without more, extinguish a GMS contract where a reconstituted partnership continues the practice under regulation 15.


It also confirms the limits of a commissioner's role. NHS England is not responsible for determining internal partnership disputes. If a membership change is thought likely to have a serious adverse effect on performance, specific statutory termination powers and safeguards must be used; automatic termination cannot be assumed.


Our Practice

News & Publications

Practical takeaway

GP partners and commissioners should distinguish carefully between dissolution of an existing partnership, reconstitution of a continuing practice, and a change from partnership contractor to sole practitioner.
The contractual and regulatory route - and the notices required - may be different in each situation.

Our role

The claimants were represented by Jason Coppel KC and Oluwaseyi Ojo, instructed by Taylor Wood Solicitors. The judicial review succeeded and the claim was allowed.

Sources

Judgment: R (Bhat and another) v NHS Litigation Au­thority and another [2024] EWHC 375 (Admin)

We’re listening.
Call 0203 786 1170

 News Main PageNext NewsPrevious News