Home

Expertise

Our Practice

Lie v Mohile [2014] EWHC 3709 (Ch)

This case raised two important legal principles.

Firstly, it answered the important question of the rights of Partners’ access to a partnership asset or property following the dissolution of the partnership and before the winding up process is completed. The Court held that the combined effect of the termination of the tenancy granted to the Partnership by one of the Partners and the dismissal of a Partner’s claim for a new tenancy was that no tenancy of the premises in favour of the partnership existed. However, that did not mean that the non-owning Partner had no right to enter the premises.

It was well established that in circumstances such as in this case, in order to give effect to the partnership, the partner who owned the premises was taken to have granted a licence to the other partner to enter the premises for the purposes of the partnership business. In the instant case, effect was given to that licence by the order continuing the injunction until the disposal of the dissolution proceedings including the winding up of the partnership affairs. In the case of a partnership, an order for dissolution was the beginning of the end, not the end in itself.

Unless and until the court appointed a receiver, the partnership business continues, albeit for the purposes of winding up the partnership. It was the right of each partner to participate in the partnership business which was being wound up. It follows that, even without an appeal, the non-owning partner has an entitlement to enter the premises.

Route of Appeal for Unallocated cases

This case also answered the question of the route of appeal where a decision or judgment of the Circuit Judge in the County Court is subject of an appeal whilst the case remains unallocated to a track.

Mr Justice David Richards (as he then was) considered an argument that an appeal in an action that had not been allocated to a track should be to the Court of Appeal. An issue arose as to whether an appeal from the order of HHJ Walden-Smith lay to the High Court or to the Court of Appeal.

It was suggested in correspondence by Dr Mohile’s solicitors that as the claim had proceeded below as if it were allocated to the multi-track, it should be treated as if it had been so allocated, with an appeal lying to the Court of Appeal. At the hearing, it was successfully argued on behalf of Dr Lie that the correct principle is as stated in CPR 52.14. It is irrelevant that the claim had been conducted like a Part 7 claim allocated to the multi-track. What the Defendant must show is that the appeal raises a point of principle and practice or there is a compelling reason why the Appeal must be heard by the Court of Appeal. As the Defendant could not satisfy the tests under CPR 52.14, the application must fail. 

The Court determined the matter and emphasised the importance of litigators familiarising themselves with the destination of appeals table in the Practice Direction 52A which sets out the destination of appeals and that the current case would come under Part 7 (not MT).  

Dr Lie was represented at the hearing by our Oluwaseyi Ojo (Solicitor Advocate).

Further information on this case can be found in PDF format.


Our Practice

Cases

Download

We’re listening.
Call 0203 786 1170

Cases Main PageNext CasePrevious Case